All CitiesNew York

Rent vs Buy in Buffalo, NY

Pre-filled with 2026 median data for Buffalo. Adjust any number to match your situation.

Median Home Price

$195,000

Median Rent/Month

$1,200

Property Tax Rate

1.72%/yr

Avg Appreciation

1.8%/yr

Adjust Your Numbers

$195,000
20% ($39,000)
$1,200
7.0%
7 years

Is It Worth Buying a Home in Buffalo, NY?

The decision to rent or buy in Buffalo, New York depends on how long you plan to stay, your down payment, and current mortgage rates. With a median home price of $195,000 and median monthly rent of $1,200, the math plays out differently depending on your personal situation.

Buffalo has an average property tax rate of 1.72% annually, which adds approximately $280/month to the cost of homeownership on a median-priced home.

Historically, home values in Buffalo have appreciated at roughly 1.8% per year, which works in favor of buyers who plan to stay long-term. Use the calculator above to find your personal break-even point.

Key Factors for Buffalo Buyers

  • Down payment of 20% on a median home = $39,000
  • Monthly mortgage (30yr at 6.99%) ≈ $1,037/mo
  • Property tax ≈ $280/mo
  • Estimated maintenance ≈ $163/mo